YourMembership.com: AMS Software Review

YourMembership AMS Software Review for Association Executives

Finding the right Association Management Software can feel like navigating a maze with over 130 options available today. For small to mid-sized associations operating with lean teams and limited budgets, the challenge becomes even more pronounced. You need a solution that doesn't require a dedicated IT department, won't break the bank, yet still delivers the functionality necessary to engage members, streamline operations, and drive non-dues revenue.

This is precisely where YourMembership by Momentive Software positions itself in the competitive AMS landscape—as an affordable, all-in-one platform specifically built for associations that need enterprise capabilities without enterprise complexity.

Summary of the YourMembership Software

YourMembership is an all-in-one association management software owned by Momentive Software, formerly known as Community Brands until the company's strategic rebranding in July 2024 following acquisition by global growth private equity firm TA Associates [1]. Headquartered in St. Petersburg, Florida, Momentive Software employs approximately 2,000 team members and serves over 30,000 purpose-driven organizations across 30 countries [2,3].

According to the company's official messaging, YourMembership has been serving the association marketplace for more than 25 years and currently supports over 13,000 nonprofit organizations and associations [4]. The platform proudly claims that "one in four association professionals" use their software, with approximately 25 million members interacting with YourMembership through their respective associations [5]. Quinn Hoffman, General Manager of YourMembership, describes their mission: "We help small to mid-sized associations deliver great member experiences and ease their workload" [6].

The company operates with a remote-first culture, offering employees flexible hybrid and remote work arrangements while maintaining additional offices in Chicago, Illinois; Austin, Texas; Groton, Connecticut; the United Kingdom; and Cebu [7].

The Purpose Statement of the YourMembership Software

YourMembership exists to empower small-staff associations to do more with less. The software's core purpose centers on three fundamental pillars: creating operational efficiency for lean teams, building meaningful member engagement, and growing revenue beyond traditional dues structures [8].

Momentive Software articulates its overarching vision as enabling purpose-driven organizations to "bring on better outcomes for everyone you serve" by delivering "an integrated ecosystem of tools designed to help nonprofits and associations enhance member and donor engagement, streamline business processes, and drive revenue and funding for greater community impact" [9]. This philosophy acknowledges that associations work hard to serve their communities while dealing with resource constraints, piecemeal solutions, or technology that simply can't keep pace with their ambitions.

What Makes YourMembership a Fit for the Association Market and Unique

YourMembership distinguishes itself through its unwavering focus on the small-staff association segment—organizations that typically don't have dedicated IT resources but still need sophisticated membership management capabilities. The platform adopts what might be called the "Swiss Army knife" approach to AMS solutions, offering comprehensive functionality without requiring associations to cobble together multiple disparate systems [10].

Several distinguishing characteristics set YourMembership apart in the crowded AMS marketplace. First, the software operates as a true cloud-based SaaS solution where all users remain on the latest version automatically, eliminating the need for costly upgrades or technical expertise to maintain the system [11]. Second, YourMembership emphasizes ease of use for non-technical staff, with an intuitive interface that allows association professionals to manage complex operations without needing to understand database architecture or coding [12].

The platform's integrated website builder deserves particular attention as it enables associations to create a customized online presence directly within the same system that manages their member data, eliminating the frustration of maintaining separate vendors for website hosting and database management [13]. Additionally,

YourMembership provides multiple non-dues revenue opportunities through built-in functionality, including an online store for merchandise and sponsorships, advertising capabilities for website and publications, integration with YM Careers job board software, and seamless connection to Freestone learning management system for educational content delivery [14].

Perhaps most critically for resource-constrained associations, YourMembership positions itself as an affordable alternative that doesn't sacrifice essential features for cost savings—though the company does not publicly disclose specific pricing, instead offering customized quotes based on organizational needs [15].

Functional Goals of the YourMembership AMS Software

YourMembership consolidates approximately 40 potential functional areas into a unified platform designed to address the core operational needs of small to mid-sized associations. The primary functional categories include:

• Membership Management: Comprehensive member database with automated workflows, membership renewals, member self-service portal, member directory, and member communication tools including email and SMS messaging [16].

• Event Management: Event registration and ticketing, waitlist automation, on-site check-in capabilities via mobile app, event promotion tools, and post-event surveys for feedback collection [17].

• Financial Management & E-Commerce: Online store functionality, integrated payment processing, accounts receivable tracking, invoicing capabilities, and seamless integration with QuickBooks Online for accounting synchronization [18].

• Communication & Engagement: Email marketing platform, text messaging capabilities, automated communications for renewals and event reminders, newsletter creation tools, and targeted segmentation for personalized outreach [19].

• Online Community: Built-in member community features including discussion forums, photo sharing, member-to-member communication, and private groups for committees or special interest sections [20].

• Website & Content Management: Integrated website builder with customizable templates, mobile-responsive design, member-only content areas, blog functionality, and document library for resource sharing [21].

• Analytics & Reporting: Customizable dashboards displaying key performance metrics, report generation and modification tools, member engagement tracking, and revenue analytics to inform strategic decision-making [22].

• Professional Development: Integration with Path LMS (Learning Management System) by Momentive Software for delivering live and on-demand educational opportunities, continuing education tracking, and certification management [23].

• Career Center: Optional integration with YM Careers job board software to provide employment opportunities for members while generating non-dues revenue from employer postings [24].

Where Does YourMembership Fit in the Market

Using the SmartThoughts Tier Classification Framework [25], YourMembership positions solidly in the Tier II-III hybrid category, with particular strength serving Tier III organizations while offering capabilities that extend into the Tier II space.

Tier Classification Rationale: YourMembership targets small to mid-sized associations, typically with operating budgets ranging from startup levels up to approximately $2.5 million, though the platform can accommodate associations with budgets exceeding this threshold [26]. The software exemplifies the "Swiss Army knife" or all-in-one approach characteristic of Tier III solutions, bundling membership management, website, events, e-commerce, accounting, and community features into a single integrated system. While this comprehensiveness provides excellent value and convenience for smaller associations, the platform offers less depth in specialized areas like advanced financial management compared to true Tier II enterprise solutions that might integrate with full-featured ERP accounting systems [27].

Competitive Landscape: Within the Tier II-III segment, YourMembership competes directly with several notable platforms:

• WildApricot represents YourMembership's closest competitor in the small association space, offering similar all-in-one functionality with transparent pricing starting at $36/month for micro-associations. WildApricot has earned consistent recognition as the #1 membership management software for six consecutive years and emphasizes its affordability and ease of use [28]. The key differentiation comes in target market size—WildApricot focuses slightly more on micro to small associations (Tier III-IV), while YourMembership extends further into the mid-sized association space (Tier II-III).

• MemberClicks serves as another close competitor, targeting small-staff associations and chambers of commerce with integrated tools for membership management, event registration, and email communication. MemberClicks emphasizes saving time and money through web-based simplification of everyday technology needs [29].

Ideal Client Profile: YourMembership fits best with associations that have the following characteristics: small-staff operations (typically 2-15 employees) seeking to consolidate multiple systems into one platform; operating budgets ranging from $500,000 to $3.5 million; limited or no dedicated IT resources; desire for automated workflows to reduce manual administrative tasks; need for integrated website and database management; aspiration to diversify revenue beyond membership dues; and willingness to accept some limitations in advanced customization in exchange for ease of use and affordability.

The Investment Costs of YourMembrership

YourMembership follows an industry-standard practice of providing customized pricing quotes rather than publishing a standard rate card. The company states that it "offers affordable pricing packages for small to mid-sized associations and member-based organizations" and emphasizes that "you don't need to break the bank for modern, all-in-one technology" [31].

Based on industry analysis and competitive positioning, small to mid-sized associations should anticipate investing approximately 6-10% of their annual operating budget in the first year of AMS implementation, which includes software subscription fees, implementation services, data conversion, training, and initial customization [32]. For ongoing years, annual costs typically range from 2-4% of the operating budget for subscription fees, support, and incremental enhancements.

YourMembership's cloud-based SaaS model offers several cost advantages: no software installation or infrastructure requirements; automatic updates included in annual pricing without additional charges; no need to employ dedicated technical staff to manage the system; and consolidated costs replacing multiple separate systems for website, email marketing, event management, and database [33].

In the end, it is recommended to contact the software vendor directly for the latest pricing information, as rates can vary significantly based on organization size, number of members, desired features, and implementation scope. Prospective customers should request a comprehensive total cost of ownership analysis that includes not just subscription fees but also implementation, training, ongoing support, and any optional add-on services like advanced integrations or custom development.

Peer Reviews and Unique Feature Insights on YM

YourMembership receives generally positive reviews across major software review platforms, with users particularly praising implementation support, customer service responsiveness, and the platform's comprehensive feature set. Analysis of 173 verified Capterra reviews reveals that most users report thorough, personalized implementation support ensuring smooth onboarding, while reviewers consistently indicate that support services are prompt, helpful, and easily accessible.

Positive User Feedback:

One Executive Director from the Legal Services sector with 2-10 employees and more than 2 years of experience enthusiastically shared:

"I greatly appreciate the 'chat with support' button that YourMembership has to have quick and easy questions answered without wasting three hours looking for a button/feature that is right in front of me". An Operations Manager from the Non-Profit Organization Management sector using the software for 6-12 months stated: "Overall, I've been very pleased with

YourMembership from initial introduction, through implementation, and into daily operations. I especially appreciated working with my Implementation Specialist, who not only guided me throughout the implementation but also spent the extra time to understand my work style to be sure her support set us up for success in the long term."

A Technology Manager/Awards Administrator with 2+ years of experience offered high praise:

"Using YourMembership has helped our organization in so many ways. As we increased our levels of expertise and professionalism, YourMembership was able to keep up with us and show us new ways to display our organization in the best light. We were able to centralize nearly all facets of our organization... The customer support teams are the best I've ever worked with. I've yet to find a support representative that hasn't been able to assist me with a problem"

Users appreciate the comprehensive membership database and effective member data management, which helps maintain current and lapsed member information. Reviewers value the integrated system and ease of use, noting that even non-technical users can create attractive web pages and manage web content efficiently.

Constructive Criticism:

However, peer reviews also reveal areas needing improvement. Some users report that website design capabilities feel outdated, slow, and not user-friendly.

One Community and Programme Manager from Telecommunications with 2-10 employees and more than 2 years of experience stated:

"Interface is too simple and not attractive, files uploading too cumbersome and website management too". Users express frustration with the lack of flexibility in customizing pages, slow website speed, and occasional interface difficulties, which can hinder the overall user experience.

A Chief Operations Officer from Education Management with 11-50 employees and more than 2 years of experience offered pointed criticism:

"The accounting side of YM is sorely lacking, as is membership tracking"

One particularly frustrated reviewer shared on support and updates:

"I have an urgent problem with YM at this moment—and you can NEVER get them on the phone. It takes HOURS and HOURS if not DAYS to get responses to problems. And the response you normally get is NO—the system can't do that—or you will manually have to edit 300 records. You can't change your membership renewal date.

Updates to the application are MINIMAL at best" YourMembership Software Reviews, Demo & Pricing - 2025.

Unique Feature Strengths:

Reviewers consistently highlight several standout capabilities: Comprehensive reporting and analytics with customizable dashboards

Integrated e-commerce and online store functionality making it easy to accept donations and sell merchandise, sponsorships, event registrations, and other non-dues items; automated workflows reducing manual administrative tasks; self-service member portal empowering members to update their own profiles and manage renewals; and SMS messaging capabilities alongside traditional email for more immediate member communication 6 things your small association will love about YourMembership AMS.

Analyst Expert Analysis and Reasoning

YourMembership represents a pragmatic choice for small to mid-sized associations seeking to consolidate their technology stack into a single, manageable platform. The software successfully delivers on its core promise of providing comprehensive functionality without requiring extensive technical expertise—a critical consideration for associations operating with small staff teams wearing multiple hats.

Strategic Strengths: The platform's greatest strength lies in its accessibility and integration. For associations currently managing membership data in spreadsheets, maintaining separate systems for events and communications, and struggling to keep their website synchronized with their database, YourMembership offers immediate relief through consolidation. The automatic cloud-based updates eliminate a significant pain point that plagues associations using legacy on-premise systems, ensuring they always have access to the latest features and security patches without project management overhead or unexpected costs.

The company's ownership by TA Associates, a global growth private equity firm with a 50-year track record and over $65 billion in capital raised, provides reassurance regarding long-term stability and investment in product development [34]. The July 2024 strategic rebranding from Community Brands to Momentive Software, combined with the appointment of enterprise software veteran Mike Mayoras as Executive Chairman, signals a sharpened focus on the association marketplace with renewed commitment to innovation [35].

The strategic partnership with Data Sangria by AMS Geek represents a forward-thinking approach to integration challenges, offering associations enhanced data portability and a more seamless technology ecosystem. This partnership addresses a critical pain point in the AMS marketplace where associations often struggle to connect their various systems effectively.

Areas of Concern: However, several legitimate concerns emerge from objective analysis. The recurring criticism about outdated website design and limited customization flexibility suggests that associations with strong brand identity needs or sophisticated design requirements may find themselves constrained. In an era where member experience increasingly drives retention, having a website that feels dated or lacks the polish members expect from consumer applications represents a competitive disadvantage.

The accounting functionality limitations represent another serious consideration, particularly for associations with complex financial structures, multiple revenue streams, or sophisticated reporting requirements for boards or external auditors. Organizations requiring accrual-based accounting, detailed fund accounting, or intricate budgeting capabilities may find themselves supplementing YourMembership with standalone accounting software, partially defeating the purpose of an all-in-one solution.

The mixed feedback regarding customer support responsiveness presents a red flag. While many users praise the support team, the existence of reviews citing days-long response times and difficulty reaching support by phone suggests inconsistency in service delivery that could prove problematic during critical situations like event registration deadlines or membership renewal campaigns.

Market Positioning Analysis: YourMembership occupies a challenging position in the AMS marketplace—caught between ultra-affordable solutions like WildApricot (with transparent pricing starting at $36/month) and more sophisticated enterprise platforms like MemberSuite or Nimble AMS that offer greater customization and scalability. This middle-market positioning can create a "squeeze" where smaller associations question the value proposition relative to cheaper alternatives, while growing associations may outgrow the platform's capabilities before fully realizing return on their implementation investment.

The lack of transparent pricing represents a double-edged sword. While customized quotes enable flexibility and potentially better value for some organizations, the absence of published pricing creates friction in the evaluation process and may deter smaller associations with limited budgets who need pricing certainty before investing time in a detailed evaluation.

Future Considerations: Associations evaluating YourMembership should carefully consider their growth trajectory and long-term needs. Organizations planning significant expansion in membership, program offerings, or complexity may find themselves questioning whether YourMembership can scale with their ambitions. Conversely, associations comfortable with their current size and primarily seeking operational efficiency improvements may find YourMembership's capabilities perfectly aligned with their needs for many years.

The ongoing investment in product development and innovation under new private equity ownership will prove critical. TA Associates' Hythem El-Nazer stated: "We see a tremendous opportunity for growth and look forward to supporting the new Momentive and uncovering opportunities that fuel product innovation and increase the value Momentive can deliver to its more than 30,000 customers across 30 countries".

The commitment to offering employee ownership at all levels suggests a culture focused on long-term value creation rather than short-term profit extraction—a positive indicator for customers evaluating partnership stability.

Bottom Line: YourMembership merits serious consideration from small to mid-sized associations seeking an integrated, user-friendly platform that consolidates essential functions without requiring significant technical resources. The software excels at solving the specific pain points of resource-constrained associations: operational efficiency through automation, member engagement through integrated communications, and revenue diversification through e-commerce capabilities.

However, associations with sophisticated design requirements, complex accounting needs, or aggressive growth plans should carefully evaluate whether the platform's capabilities will meet their needs three to five years into the future, not just today. The best candidates for YourMembership success are organizations that prioritize ease of use and integration over deep customization, value reliable support over cutting-edge features, and seek sustainable operational efficiency improvements rather than transformational technological innovation.

Verified Association Executives are encouraged to schedule a conversation to explore whether YourMembership aligns with your association's unique needs and strategic direction. To access our comprehensive Smart Report analysis of YourMembership with detailed feature scoring, competitive benchmarking, and implementation guidance, please reach out for a complimentary evaluation consultation.

Sources Cited

[1] Community Brands. "Community Brands is now Momentive Software." January 27, 2025. https://www.communitybrands.com/company/news/community-brands-is-now-momentive-software/

[2] PitchBook. "Momentive Software 2025 Company Profile." https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/179533-09

[3] Momentive Software. "About Us." January 13, 2025. https://momentivesoftware.com/about-us/

[4] Crunchbase. "Momentive Software." https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/community-brands

[5] YourMembership. "All-In-One Association Member Management System." January 22, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/

[6] YourMembership. "YourMembership by Momentive Software Announces New Partnership with Data Sangria by AMS Geek." May 22, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/new-partnership-with-data-sangria/

[7] Momentive Software. "Careers at Momentive Software." January 13, 2025. https://momentivesoftware.com/careers/

[8] Momentive Software. "Association Management Software | Drive Growth." August 28, 2025. https://momentivesoftware.com/solutions/association-management-software/

[9] Momentive Software. "Leading Software for Nonprofits." January 10, 2025. https://momentivesoftware.com/

[10] YourMembership. "Find the Right Association Management Software." August 12, 2025. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/find-the-right-association-management-software-for-small-staff/

[11] YourMembership. "6 things your small association will love about YourMembership AMS." December 9, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/love-yourmembership-ams/

[12] YourMembership. "Member retention made easy for small associations: Top strategies for 2025." March 21, 2025. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/member-retention/

[13] Capterra. "YourMembership Reviews 2025." https://www.capterra.com/p/76329/YourMembership/reviews/

[14] YourMembership. "How to pay for a new AMS system with non-dues revenue." September 28, 2023. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/new-ams/

[15] YourMembership. "YourMembership Member Software Pricing Request." December 13, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/products/association-management-software/pricing/demo/

[16] G2. "YourMembership Reviews 2025." https://www.g2.com/products/yourmembership/reviews

[17] LinkedIn. "YourMembership by Momentive Software." https://www.linkedin.com/showcase/yourmembership-com/

[18] Software Advice. "YourMembership Software Reviews, Demo & Pricing - 2025." https://www.softwareadvice.com/nonprofit/yourmembership-profile/

[19] YourMembership. "6 things your small association will love about YourMembership AMS." December 9, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/love-yourmembership-ams/

[20] YourMembership. "All-In-One Association Member Management System." January 22, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/

[21] Capterra. "YourMembership Pricing, Alternatives & More 2025." https://www.capterra.com/p/76329/YourMembership/

[22] Software Advice. "YourMembership Software Reviews." https://www.softwareadvice.com/nonprofit/yourmembership-profile/

[23] YourMembership. "6 things your small association will love about YourMembership AMS." December 9, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/love-yourmembership-ams/

[24] YourMembership. "6 things your small association will love about YourMembership AMS." December 9, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/love-yourmembership-ams/

[25] SmartThoughts. "Membership Software Tiers: Where Do You Fit." https://www.smartthoughts.net/post/membership-software-tiers-where-do-you-fit

[26] YourMembership. "Find the Right Association Management Software." August 12, 2025. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/find-the-right-association-management-software-for-small-staff/

[27] Capterra. "YourMembership Pricing, Alternatives & More 2025." https://www.capterra.com/p/76329/YourMembership/

[28] WildApricot. "#1 Membership Management Software Award (6 years in a row)." July 17, 2022. https://www.wildapricot.com/

[29] G2. "Top 10 YourMembership Alternatives 2022." https://www.g2.com/products/yourmembership/competitors/alternatives

[30] SaaSworthy. "Top 5 Alternatives to YourMembership (January 2025)." January 15, 2025. https://www.saasworthy.com/product-alternative/6975/yourmembership

[31] YourMembership. "YourMembership Member Software Pricing Request." December 13, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/products/association-management-software/pricing/demo/

[32] YourMembership. "The Ultimate Association Management Software Pricing Guide." January 8, 2025. https://www.yourmembership.com/resources/whitepapers/much-ams-really-cost/

[33] YourMembership. "How to calculate AMS total cost of ownership." December 10, 2024. https://www.yourmembership.com/blog/ams-total-cost-of-ownership/

[34] Community Brands. "Community Brands is now Momentive Software." January 27, 2025. https://www.communitybrands.com/company/news/community-brands-is-now-momentive-software/

[35] Community Brands. "Community Brands is now Momentive Software." January 27, 2025. https://www.communitybrands.com/company/news/community-brands-is-now-momentive-software/