Membership Software List: 100+
Association Management Systems
Choosing the right membership software from over 100 options can be overwhelming for association executives. This independent directory categorizes platforms based on organization size, budget, and specific needs, making it easier for you to find the best fit quickly. At the end of the directory, you’ll find a complete request list available for any verified nonprofit association.
Last Updated: October 2025 | Systems Tracked: 100+ | Vendor Payments: $0
Real Story:
When a 2,500-member professional society asked us to evaluate their software finalists, we discovered their "top choice" couldn't handle chapter management—their #1 requirement buried on page 3 of their internal needs document. That mistake would have cost a minimum of $85,000 in the first year alone. Twenty minutes reviewing this page would have likely saved them from a catastrophic decision.
About This AMS Membership Directory
This membership software directory is maintained by SmartThoughts, independent AMS selection consultants serving associations since 1998. We update this resource quarterly and receive zero payments from vendors for inclusion or placement.
Why This List Is Different:
-
✅ 100% vendor-neutral—no paid placements or affiliate commissions
-
✅ Organized by decision criteria (tier, size, budget, type) not alphabetically
-
✅ Based on our proprietary tier classification framework developed over 25+ years
-
✅ Updated October 2025 with current market conditions
-
✅ Backed by 400+ successful software selection projects
-
✅ Free resource for the association community
Our Mission: Help associations make informed software decisions within their appropriate tier without vendor bias.
This list, like many others, is only as accurate as the last day it was prepared. Therefore, please take it with a "grain of salt." We strive for accuracy and completeness, but there may still be errors. It’s important to consult a trusted advisor, such as SmartThoughts, or to contact the vendor directly to ensure the information is current.
It is meant to assist with Quick Navigation; however, it is not intended to replace the internal due diligence conducted with precise measurements and clear insights.
We will categorize this list as follows:
By Budget | By Specialization | Alphabetical List | Selection Guide
Budget-Friendly
Perfect for volunteer-led associations with limited revenue
Sample Budget-Friendly Systems:
Mid-Range Investment
Sample Mid-Range to Low Mid-Range Systems:
Enterprise Investment
Sample Enterprise Systems:
Budget Reality Check:
Software cost is an estimated 40-50% of total first-year investment. Implementation, data migration, training, and customization add 50-100% more. A "$12,000/year" system becomes $30,000+ in year one.
Request our Total Cost Calculator showing all hidden costs vendors don't disclose upfront.
Specialized Systems By Association Type {#specialty}
Trade Associations
Systems designed for industry groups with corporate members and likely an advocacy focus
Sample Choices: iMIS, Aptify, AVECTRA NetForum, Nimble AMS, MemberzPlus, Advanced AMS, reMembers
Professional Societies
Platforms optimized for individual professionals with certifications and continuing education. To be fair, most AMS options will be able to help to some degree with the needs of a professional society.
Sample Choices: iMIS, Aptify, Higher Logic, MemberSuite, YourMembership, Fonteva, reMembers
Chambers of Commerce
Solutions built for local business networking and economic development organizations.
Sample Choices: MemberClicks, GrowthZone/ChamberMaster, CC-Assist, Glue Up, Accrisoft Freedom
Alumni/Educational Associations
Platforms for schools, universities, and alumni engagement.
Sample Choices: iModules (Anthology), ToucanTech, VeryConnect, Alumni Spaces
HOAs & Community Associations
Systems designed for homeowner associations and property management
Sample Choices: TOPS [ONE], Caliber HOA, AtHomeNet
Labor Unions
Platforms with union-specific features like grievance tracking and strike management
Sample Choices: LabourWare, UnionWare
Licensing Boards
Systems for professional regulatory bodies managing licenses and compliance.
Sample Choices: In1Touch Software, MINASU
Fraternal Organizations
Greek life and fraternal management systems.
Sample Choices: GreekTrack, OmegaFi
Churches & Faith-Based Organizations
Church management systems with membership tracking.
Sample Choices: Fresh Vine, Fellowship One, Planning Center
How to Choose from 100+ Options {#choose}
Understanding AMS Tiers: The NCAA Division Approach
Just as the NCAA uses divisions to organize college athletics based on resources, competition level, and institutional characteristics, the AMS market segments into tiers. Understanding which tier matches your association is the critical first step—before spending time evaluating solutions in the wrong category.
The tier classification framework was developed by SmartThoughts over a decade ago to address the complexity of the association management software marketplace. This methodology has been refined through hundreds of software selection projects and aligns with industry-standard analyst practices used by Gartner and Forrester.
Important: These tiers are not about "better" or "worse"—they're about appropriate fit. A Tier III system isn't inferior to a Tier I system any more than a Division III college is inferior to a Division I school. They serve different organizational contexts.
Tier IV: Micro-Association Software
-
Operating Budget: Startup to less than $1 million
-
Typical Member Count: Under 200 members
-
IT Resources: No dedicated IT staff
Characteristics:
-
Website-based systems that include content management, forms, hosting, and templates
-
Basic billing of dues and event registration
-
Often built on CMS platforms like WordPress with membership plugins
-
Limited depth in events, billing, and website management
-
Very basic financial management (cash basis only)
-
Extremely limited customization options
Sample Systems: MemberPress, Zenbership, MembershipWorks, EZSignUp,MemberMouse
Best For: Volunteer-led organizations, startup associations, groups with straightforward membership needs
Tier III: Small Association Software
-
Operating Budget: Up to $3 million (general guideline with outliers)
-
Typical Member Count: 200-2,000 members
-
IT Resources: Limited or part-time IT support
Characteristics:
-
"Swiss Army knife" approach—all-in-one solutions
-
Good features but less depth in areas like conference management, CRM, and accounting
-
Accounts receivable may be limited to a cash basis
-
General ledger integration is limited to the summary level
-
Constrained customization (e.g., limited number of custom fields allowed)
-
Focused on ease of use and quick implementation
Sample Systems: MemberClicks, Glue Up, Aevus, ToucanTech, GrowthZone, Membes
Best For: Growing associations, organizations with straightforward workflows, limited technical resources
Tier II: Mid-Size Association Software
-
Operating Budget: $2.5 million or more
-
Typical Member Count: 2,000-10,000 members
-
IT Resources: Dedicated staff or contractor
Characteristics:
-
Strong core membership functions with greater depth in billing, events, and e-commerce
-
Focus on core member database and member portals
-
Often excludes some functional areas (associations use best-of-breed for CMS, email marketing)
-
Financial management supports both cash and accrual-based accounting
-
More flexible customization options than Tier III
-
Professional services available for implementation and training
Sample Systems: iMIS, Fonteva, YourMembership, MemberSuite, reMembers, Personify
Best For: Established associations with complex workflows, organizations requiring deeper feature functionality, and groups with moderate technical resources
Tier I: Enterprise Association Software
-
Operating Budget: $5 million minimum, typically much higher
-
Typical Member Count: 10,000+ members
-
IT Resources: Dedicated IT team or department
Characteristics:
-
Comprehensive and sophisticated systems designed for large national organizations
-
Flexible and powerful core database with open API
-
Extensive options to tailor functionality to complex requirements
-
Advanced analytics and reporting including data mining and executive dashboards
-
Professional services for setup, training, tailoring, and business process consulting
-
Support for multi-chapter operations, international requirements, complex dues structures
Sample Systems: Aptify, AVECTRA NetForum, MemberzPlus, Higher Logic, Nimble AMS, Advanced AMS
Best For: Large national or international associations, organizations with complex multi-entity structures, associations requiring extensive customization and integration
The 4-Stage Selection Framework
STAGE 1: Identify Your Tier (Week 1)
Determine your tier based on:
-
Annual operating budget (most reliable indicator)
-
Current member count and 3-year growth projection
-
Complexity of membership structure (individual vs. corporate, single vs. multi-chapter)
-
IT resources available
-
Required feature depth vs. breadth
Most critical mistake: Comparing systems across tiers. A Tier IV association evaluating Tier I systems will find them overwhelming and expensive. A Tier I association implementing a Tier III system will quickly outgrow it.
And, for a free, quick assessment, learn more here.
STAGE 2: Identify Your Top 5 Must-Haves (Week 2)
Within your tier, rank your requirements:
-
Automated renewal processing
-
Member self-service portal
-
Event registration and management
-
Integrated payment processing
-
Email marketing and communications
-
Mobile access for members
-
Reporting and analytics
-
Learning management system (LMS)
-
Chapter/component management
-
Certification tracking
Reality check: Systems with 50+ features overwhelm small associations. Focus on what you'll actually use in year one.
STAGE 3: Calculate Total Cost (Week 3)
Budget these expenses, such as software license, implementation, training, and internal or external project management fees.
STAGE 4: Demo & Validate (Weeks 4-6)
Schedule demos with not more than 3 finalists within your tier. Bring your team:
-
Executive director (budget authority)
-
Membership manager (daily user)
-
Finance/accounting (integration needs)
-
Board member (governance perspective)
Ask every vendor these sample questions:
-
"Show us how your system handles [your specific workflow]"
-
"What's your typical implementation timeline for organizations in our tier?"
-
"Provide 3 references from associations of our size in our sector."
-
"What percentage of clients in our tier successfully migrate within 6 months?"
-
"What happens if we're unhappy after 90 days?"
Validate references: Call them. Ask about implementation pain points, hidden costs, and whether they'd choose the same system again.
Why Most Associations Get This Wrong {#help}
The Big Mistake
A 3,200-member trade association (Tier II) spent 14 months evaluating systems. They chose based on impressive demos and the lowest price—a Tier III system stretched to its limits. Four months into implementation, they discovered:
-
The system couldn't handle their corporate + individual dual membership structure
-
Data migration failed twice, losing 3 years of event history
-
Training took 4x longer than estimated
-
Staff threatened to quit over the terrible user interface
-
The board demanded they switch systems
Total cost of the mistake: $85,000 in implementation fees, lost staff time, and starting over with a Tier II system.
What went wrong:
They evaluated features, not tier fit. They trusted vendor promises that the system could "scale up" over independent validation. They didn't understand the constraints built into Tier III systems.
How to Avoid This
The SmartThoughts Advantage: We've guided 400+ associations through software selection since 1998. We developed the tier classification framework specifically to prevent these expensive mismatches. We know which systems actually work for $800K budget chambers vs. $8M budget professional societies.
Our process:
-
Requirements Workshop: We document what you actually need, not what vendors want to sell
-
Tier Analysis: We identify your proper tier and narrow 100+ options to the 8-12 systems in your category
-
Shortlist Development: We identify your top 3-5 based on fit, not features
-
Demo Facilitation: We attend demos with you, asking the hard questions vendors hate
-
Reference Validation: We call references and ask what really happened
-
Contract Review: We negotiate better terms and catch hidden costs
-
Implementation Oversight: We ensure vendors deliver what they promised
Our guarantee:
You will make the right decision in 8 to 12 weeks instead of 12 to 18 months of DIY or continuously postponing it.
Complete Alphabetical AMS Directory
A-C
Aevus, Accrisoft Freedom, Advanced AMS, Advanced Solutions iMIS, Alumni Spaces, AMO, AM.NET, AMSoft MINASU, Aptify, Arco, Asseance Society Manager, Associately, Association Manager, AssociationServer, AtHomeNet, AVECTRA NetForum, AXIS, aarwinMEP, CC-Assist, CE21 LightHouse AMS, Configio, Creative Computer Services, CRM MemberManager
D-J
Dashboard, DAXKO Connect, Digital Access Pass, eSuite Tools, Fresh Vine, Glue Up, GoMembers OnDemand, GoMembers Enterprise, GreekTrack, Guild Solutions, Heuristics Solutions, iModules (Anthology), Impact Solutions MemberMax, In1Touch Software, InfusionSoft (Keap), Intelink InTouchOnDemand, JL Systems, Joyn AMS
L-N
LabourWare, Mass Member System, Membes, MemberClicks, MemberConnection, MemberFind.me, Memberium, MemberLeap, MemLink, MemberPlex, Memberrize, MEMBERS ONLY Cumulus, Membersavenue, MemberSpace, MemberStack, MemberzPlus, Membership Toolkit, MembershipWorks, MemEX Online, MINASU AMSoft, Navantis, Nimble AMS
O-S
Oasis Computing, Paid Membership Pro, PeakAMS, Rappatoni, Readymembership, reMembers, S2 Member
T-Z
TCS Software WebSuite2, Tendenci, TOPS [ONE], ToucanTech, TradeWing, VeryConnect, Waterfall, Weblink International, Wild Apricot, WishList Member, X-CD Technologies, Your People, Zenbership
Frequently Asked Questions
How many membership software options exist?
Over 100 platforms serve associations, ranging from $25/month for volunteer organizations to $100,000+ annually for large national associations. The market segments into four tiers based on organizational budget and complexity. The challenge isn't finding options—it's identifying which tier matches your association and which 3-5 systems within that tier actually fit your specific requirements.
What's the best membership software for small associations?
The answer depends on your tier. Tier IV associations (startup to $1M budget) should evaluate Wild Apricot, Membes, Joyn AMS, or MembershipWorks. Tier III associations (up to $2.5M budget) need more robust systems like MemberClicks, Glue Up, Aevus, or ToucanTech. The "best" system aligns with your budget tier, technical resources, and workflow complexity—a chamber of commerce needs different features than a professional society.
How much does membership software actually cost?
Sample and estimated budget for total first-year investment based on your tier, not just software fees:
Tier IV (Startup to $1M budget):
-
Software: $300-$3,000/year
-
Implementation: $500-$2,000
-
Training: $0-$500
-
Total Year 1: $800-$5,500
Tier III (Up to $2.5M budget):
-
Software: $3,000-$15,000/year
-
Implementation: $2,000-$8,000
-
Data migration: $2,000-$10,000
-
Training: $1,000-$3,000
-
Total Year 1: $8,000-$36,000
Tier II ($2.5M+ budget):
-
Software: $15,000-$60,000/year
-
Implementation: $10,000-$40,000
-
Data migration: $10,000-$30,000
-
Training: $3,000-$8,000
-
Customization: $5,000-$50,000
-
Total Year 1: $43,000-$188,000
Tier I ($5M+ budget):
-
Software: $60,000-$180,000+/year
-
Implementation: $40,000-$150,000
-
Data migration: $30,000-$100,000
-
Training: $10,000-$30,000
-
Customization: $50,000-$250,000
-
Total Year 1: $190,000-$710,000+
Hidden costs vendors don't disclose: additional user fees, premium support charges, customization hourly rates ($150-$300/hour), third-party integration fees, and data storage overages.
What features should associations prioritize in membership software?
Feature priorities depend on your situation, requirements, mission, assets, and budget. They are not based on a rule of thumb or tiers. However, here is a sample of some features you should realistically consider.
Tier IV & III: Focus on essentials that drive immediate value:
-
Automated renewal processing (15-25% improvement in renewal rates)
-
Member self-service portal (reduces staff time 40%)
-
Integrated payment processing (eliminates manual data entry)
-
Event registration (primary revenue driver)
-
Email marketing (member engagement)
Tier II & I: Add depth and complexity:
6. Advanced reporting and analytics (measure engagement and ROI)
7. Learning management system (certifications, CE credits)
8. Chapter/component management (multi-entity operations)
9. Certification tracking (professional credentialing)
10. API and integrations (connect best-of-breed systems)
Don't pay for Tier I features when you're a Tier III organization. Match features to your actual workflows and tier capabilities.
Can associations switch membership software easily?
In recent years, we have observed that associations are switching more frequently. One of the main reasons for this trend is the rise of the SaaS (Software as a Service) model. However, deciding whether to switch depends on your specific circumstances. It’s important to note that the difficulty of switching increases with the complexity of the tier. Here are some guidelines to consider:
Tier IV & III migrations (3-6 months):
-
Relatively straightforward with clean data
-
Limited customization to recreate
-
Budget $5,000-$15,000 beyond software costs
Tier II migrations (6-9 months):
-
More complex due to integrations and customizations
-
Requires thorough data cleaning and mapping
-
Budget $15,000-$40,000 beyond software costs
Tier I migrations (9-18 months):
-
Highly complex due to extensive customizations
-
Multiple system integrations to rebuild
-
Multi-chapter or international data considerations
-
Budget $40,000-$150,000+ beyond software costs
Key success factors for all tiers include ensuring clean data before migration, obtaining written vendor migration commitments, conducting parallel systems testing, providing thorough staff training (a minimum of 20-40 hours), and implementing a phased rollout for members. It is important to note that DIY migrations have a high failure rate of 40%. This is a sorrowful reality.
Why are there so many membership software options?
Twenty years ago, there were significantly fewer AMS options available—less than two dozen, in fact. The technology landscape changed drastically when SaaS became mainstream, leading to a tremendous proliferation of new systems. Now, with the addition of AI, we anticipate even more software vendors entering this sector. As a result, selecting the right fit is likely to become more challenging.
The association management software market is segmented by tier to accommodate different organizational contexts. Each tier is expected to grow, with lower-tier options continuing to lead the market with more choices.
-
Tier IV (Micro): Website-based systems for volunteer-led organizations with minimal budgets
-
Tier III (Small): All-in-one "Swiss Army knife" platforms balancing features with ease of use
-
Tier II (Mid-size): Deeper functionality in core areas, integrates with best-of-breed tools
-
Tier I (Enterprise): Comprehensive, sophisticated systems for complex national organizations
Additional segmentation by association type (trade associations, professional societies, chambers of commerce, alumni groups, HOAs, labor unions, licensing boards) and business model (all-in-one vs. platform-based vs. open-source).
This diversity enables associations to find suitable solutions within their tier, rather than forcing mismatched implementations.
How long does it take to select membership software with professional help?
Professional selection takes 8-12 weeks:
-
Weeks 1-2: Requirements documentation and tier identification
-
Weeks 3-4: Shortlist development (narrow 100+ to 3-5 within your tier)
-
Weeks 5-7: Vendor demos and reference checks
-
Weeks 8-10: Evaluation scoring and finalist selection
-
Weeks 11-12: Contract negotiation and finalization
-
Versus DIY selection: 12-18 months
Why the difference?
Consultants immediately identify your tier (eliminating 80+ wrong-fit systems), know which questions reveal fit vs. features, understand tier-specific constraints, and recognize which vendor promises are realistic vs. vaporware. You're buying 25 years of pattern recognition and hundreds of successful implementations.
What are the biggest software selection mistakes associations make?
Top 10 costly mistakes:
-
Evaluating systems outside your tier (Tier III association selecting Tier I system, or vice versa)
-
Choosing based on demos, not documented requirements (impressive demos ≠ , good fit)
-
Believing vendors who say their system can "scale up or down" (tier constraints are real)
-
Underestimating data migration complexity (assuming "clean data" when it's actually a mess)
-
Ignoring the total cost of ownership (focusing only on software fees, missing implementation costs)
-
Purchasing features beyond your tier's needs (paying for Tier I complexity in a Tier III organization)
-
Skipping reference calls within your tier (trusting vendor-selected case studies instead)
-
Rushing the decision due to renewal pressure (signing bad contracts to avoid current system pain)
-
Excluding key stakeholders from evaluation (staff discovered critical missing features after the contract was signed)
-
Not validating vendor implementation capacity for your tier (vendors overselling leads to 9-month delays)
Each mistake costs $15,000-$100,000 to fix. Professional guidance prevents them from 5-10% of software investment.
Should I hire an independent consultant for AMS selection?
Consider hiring a consultant if:
✅ You're unsure which tier your association belongs in
✅ Your current system can't support growth
✅ You're using 3+ disconnected systems
✅ You lack in-house technology expertise
✅ You've never selected association software before
✅ Your board demands vendor-neutral evaluation
✅ You want to maximize ROI and minimize risk
✅ You can't afford a $50K-$500K tier mismatch
✅ You value 6-12 months of your time
Typical ROI on consulting:
-
Proper tier identification: Prevents $50K-$500K tier mismatch disasters
-
Vendor negotiation: 15-30% better pricing = $5K-$50K savings
-
Avoiding wrong choice: Prevents implementation failure and restart costs
-
Time savings: 6-12 months of staff time = $15K-$60K value
-
Implementation oversight: Reduces timeline 30-40% = $10K-$40K savings
Total value: $80K-$650K on average
Consultant cost: $8K-$25K for selection
Net ROI: 3:1 to 26:1 return on investment
Does SmartThoughts receive vendor commissions or referral fees?
No. SmartThoughts maintains complete independence with zero financial relationships with any AMS vendor. We receive no commissions, referral fees, partnership payments, marketing development funds, or any other form of compensation from software companies.
Our business model: Associations pay us directly for unbiased guidance. This ensures our recommendations are based solely on your best interests and proper tier fit, not vendor economics.
Why this matters: Vendor-funded "consultants" recommend systems that pay the highest commissions (15-30% of contract value), not systems that best fit your tier and needs. Independent consultants recommend what's actually right for your organizational context.
Added value: We developed the tier classification framework specifically to prevent expensive tier mismatches that waste hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Ready to Stop Feeling Overwhelmed?
You've reviewed 100+ options. You understand the four tiers. You know what features matter.
Now what?
Most association executives spend another 4-6 months:
-
Requesting demos from systems in the wrong tier
-
Sitting through sales pitches disguised as consultations
-
Comparing feature lists that all sound the same
-
Second-guessing every decision
-
Explaining to the board why this is taking so long
There's a faster path.
In 30 minutes, we'll:
-
Identify your appropriate tier (eliminating 80+ wrong-fit systems immediately)
-
Explain tier-specific constraints that vendors won't disclose
-
Pinpoint your must-have features vs. nice-to-haves within your tier
-
Recommend 3-5 finalists worth your demo time
-
Warn you about red flags specific to your tier and situation
-
Outline a realistic timeline and budget for your tier
No obligation. No pressure. No vendor sales pitches. Just 25+ years of expertise helping associations exactly like yours avoid expensive tier mismatches and make the right decision the first time.